Young God Records – 30th May 2025
Christopher Nosnibor
And so we arrive at the end of another era in the epic history of Swans. When they called it a day in 1996 with Soundtracks for the Blind, and a farewell tour documented on Swans are Dead, it really did seem as if that was it. Swans had run their course, and the colossal Soundtracks double CD summarised everything they had achieved over
It may seem strange that the bookend to this phase of their career should be titled Birthing. But such is the cycle of life, and indeed, the avant-garde: death gives way to new life, to build anew one must first destroy. And so in this context, Birthing, which Gira has announced will be the last release of this epic, maximalist phase, makes sense. With a running time of a hundred and fifteen minutes, it’s comparable in duration to its predecessor, The Beggar, and The Glowing Man (a hundred and twenty-one minutes and a hundred and eighteen minutes respectively) , but on this outing, the individual pieces are all immense in proportion, with the album containing just seven tracks, with only one clocking in at less than ten minutes.
‘The Healers’ makes for a suitably atmospheric, slow-burning opener. Around seven minutes in, the gentle eddying begins to swell, like a breeze which wisps and ruffles the leaves on the trees – a minute or so later, the drums have entered the mix, and the ambient drift begins to take a more solid form, and there’s a change in the air temperature, the barometer plummets and the breeze becomes a wind. In no time, there’s a swirling wail of sound surrounding Gira’s increasingly exultant enunciations, but as he growls and mumbles and raises his voice higher, he’s increasingly drowned by the maelstrom. And yet, it’s nowhere near a crescendo, and I’m reminded of their set on the 2013 tour, where, having told my friend that having seen them in the same venue three years previous that they took volume to another level, the first twenty minutes of the set was loud, but not remarkably so – and then suddenly, there was a leap of around thirty percent that felt like a double-footed kick in the chest. Will it happen here? Around the fifteen minute mark, it tapers down to a haunting whistle of wind – and it’s the calm before the storm, as a raging tempest suddenly erupts, a frenzied wall of noise that has become their signature, and the song surges to a powerful sustained climax.
While the delivery is considerably less brutal than it was in the early 80s, Gira’s lyrics are still riven with dark and disturbing imagery, and now coloured with a hint of abstraction and madness, and this is nowhere more evident than on ‘I Am a Tower’, which was aired as a lyric video a little while ago. ‘With thin boneless fingers and pink polished nails, I’m searching for the fat folds of your blunder. Speak up, Dick! …Bring your fish-headed fixer to whisper in my ear. Please worry me here, tongue that victim in there…’ he intones like a cracked messianic cult leader against a backdrop of swirling drones. Attempting to unpick sense or meaning from it feels futile, and potentially traumatic, so instead, it’s perhaps experienced holistically, as a jumble of images and impressions, a fractured collage, a derangement of the senses whereby you allow it to transport you to another plane, away from anything concrete or grounded, beyond all that you know. Seemingly from nowhere, a motorik rhythm kicks in and we get something approximating a driving Krauty post-rock riff, hook and all. It could be Swans’ most pop moment since the White Light / Love of Life albums in the early 90s.
The title track arrives in a ripple of proggy synth that has a hint of Mike Oldfield about it, but gradually builds into a dramatic swell of sound, the likes of which has come to characterise the last decade of Swans, with a single chord struck repeatedly for what feels like an eternity. And then, from nowhere, they launch into something approximating a jig – on a loop, where the bass and drums simply hammer away repeatedly, like a stuck record. It is, if course, pure hypnotic magnificence. Gira’s words slip into soporific sedation amidst descending piano rolls. ‘Does it end? Will it end?’ he asks at the start of an extend wind-down, and it does feel like this would make a perfect gentle close – but there are more jarring, jolting ruptures to come, whipping up a truly punishing climax by way of a close, and by the end of the first disc – a full hour in duration – we’re left drained and hollowed out, tossed this way and that on a sonic – and emotional – tempest only Swans could create. Disc one, then, feels like a compete album. But this is a Swans release, and a landmark one, at that there isa whole further album’s worth of material yet.
‘Red Yellow’ begins in a dreamy drift, but soon slides into a warping drone pitched against another of those relentless, repetitive grooves, this time with some jazz horns freaking out in every direction. And at this point, there does arise the question of what new this iteration of Swans is offering at this point, but the immense, immersive soundscapes provide the answer in themselves. Swans have certainly evolved, but they have always done so gradually. The first half of the eighties was devoted to crushing slow grind, and you’d have to be a glutton for punishment to listen to more than one album in a sitting. The point is that Swans have always pleased themselves and made music that tests the listener’s limits, and Birthing is no exception.
Reviewing a Swans album is always a challenge, especially their comeback releases. They’re not about songs, and, broadly speaking, not really about impact in the way their early works were: instead, they’re about transcendence, about moving beyond mere music.
‘Guardian Spirit’ starts out textured an atmospheric, but ends full Merzbow, before ‘The Merge’ takes noise to the next level, albeit briefly. It’s as if Gira is toying with us. Perhaps he is, but when the noise erupts, it really erupts. ‘Rope’ returns us full cycle to there My Father Will Guide Me, while making an obvious connection with all phases of their career, through which ropes and hangings have been a perpetual theme.
Birthing is not an easy album, but it is one which requires listeners (and reviewers) to do something different in terms of approach. You don’t listen so much a feel it, and ride its endless waves: sometimes slow, gentle, at others an absolute roar, Birthing brings together everything Swans have done, and achieved, over the course of this iteration. It’s often overwhelming, and almost impossible to reduce to words. The second disc does feel softer, more abstract, and leaves on wondering precisely what the next phase will look or sound like.
Aural Aggravation 